By: TRIADA Studio
I only knew about Shadowmatic a few weeks before its release, but the second I saw video of it, I couldn’t wait to get my hands on the game. It looked like something that had the potential to be a real classic and, if done right, the perfect touchscreen game. It has a simple idea paired with photorealistic graphics and what could be both relaxing and challenging at the same time.
The way the game works is you’re first given an abstract object in a spotlight. Your task is to rotate the object until its shadow resembles something less abstract. Early on, the solutions are fairly easy, and shouldn’t offer too much trouble. Then you’re introduced to puzzles with two pieces and things get really interesting. Controlling the two pieces is pretty intuitive, so those levels are often challenging but not overly frustrating. This is the game’s sweet spot.
Then the game introduces three-piece puzzles. This is where things start to fall apart and the game started to lose some of its magic for me. The once-simple and intuitive controls become a balancing act in these levels. Sometimes you need to have three fingers on the small iPhone screen, and if one finger moves slightly off the button in the lower left hand corner, the two pieces that were perfectly matched up will now break apart. These levels are certainly doable, as I and many others completed the game in its entirety. But it introduces an unnecessary level of frustration to an otherwise relaxing game.
The game does have a progress meter at the bottom of the screen that tells you when you’re getting close to a solution. Unfortunately, it’s not always so helpful, especially with the three-piece puzzles. You can have all three pieces in the right spot, but if one is facing the wrong direction (even though it looks the same either way), the game won’t even give you one light on the meter. The second you flip that piece, it would go from zero lights to all six lights. Other times, you can get to 5.5 lights out of 6 and the game will be so stingy about that last half light.
Based on the videos released and the hints system, I did have some concerns before the game came out. I expressed them in this blog post here. The gist of it is that I saw the great potential of this game if it put the players first by allowing them to play the levels in any order they want. But I had this gut feeling that wouldn’t be the case. Sadly, I was right. While the game advertises non-linear gameplay, this only means that sometimes you’ll have more than one level available to play at the same time. But you still need to unlock the levels in a specific order. You cannot skip any if you’re having trouble with it. Your only options when you’re stuck are to use in-game hints (you earn some just by playing but can also purchase them with IAPs), find help elsewhere (like my walkthrough) or to simply quit playing.
There is no logical reason for the game to force players to play in a linear fashion once all the mechanics are introduced. While each section (or world) has a theme, solving one level in that section doesn’t necessarily help you solve another. The themes are sometimes too broad without any other hints to go on, and they don’t help so much with a lot of the solutions as just having the shapes “speak” to you.
Some of the answers are so abstract that I ended up using some hints rather than quitting outright. And sometimes I had trouble with a shape even while knowing what the game wanted. For instance, the game’s version of a key isn’t like any key I would have pictured in a million years. I also guessed a couple of answers from the first hints given, but still couldn’t make sense of the shape. One time, I was so sure that the game wanted me to make a Pi symbol because I was close to a very convincing one, but it turned out to just be a regular letter of the alphabet.
In other instances, I knew exactly what shape I needed to make, but the game wouldn’t recognize the shape until it was just so. Even on the third or fourth time solving a three-piece puzzle, I came across these issues. The sensitivity of the controls also became a problem in three-piece puzzles later in the game. Simply lifting my fingers off the screen would cause the pieces to move unintentionally, turning five-and-a-half lights on the progress meter into four. If you don’t mind the spoilers, you can watch this video to see what I mean:
In addition to the main solutions, a number of levels have secret solutions which are completely optional. The shadows are shown in a list, but it’s up to the player to figure out how to make them. This is a really cool idea and some nice additional content, but would be better if it didn’t take a huge stretch of the imagination to see the shapes as the developers intended. For example, this is supposed to be a shaman:
Because of all this, Shadowmatic often veers from relaxing puzzler to a frustrating exercise in patience. The game is still a gorgeous piece of artwork and an incredibly unique idea that I’m glad saw the light of day. But too many things have been overlooked that keep it from being that perfect classic that you recommend to everyone you meet, even your grandma.
All that said, it’s still a marvel to behold. If you want a truly unique gaming experience and can live with its flaws and the fact that you might not be able to complete the game without help, give Shadowmatic a download here.Download
If you find yourself stuck, try my complete walkthrough guide with all solutions, which now includes video for all levels.
Note: Sometimes a promo code is provided for a game, but it does not affect the review in any way. At AppUnwrapper, we strive to provide reviews of the utmost quality.
Check out my recommended list for other games you might like.
If you like what you see on AppUnwrapper.com, please consider supporting the site through Patreon. Every little bit helps and is greatly appreciated. You can read more about it here. And as always, if you like what you see, please help others find it by sharing it.
I also offer affordable testing and consulting for iOS developers.
COPYRIGHT NOTICE © AppUnwrapper 2011-2017. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author is strictly prohibited. Links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to AppUnwrapper with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.